According to my calculations, 30# shocks should have worked. I tried 30# and they were too weak. So I tried the 40's. They held the door up but just barely. I think you will find the 50's are best. With the 50's, the door is no harder to close than a Tahoe or something like that. I'm an engineer by trade and did the statics equation to figure out the correct poundage and like a said the 30's should have worked. I guess when you add in the extra friction from placing the gas shocks inside the original chrome tubes it adds up.
As far as the piston length, I tried a couple different lengths in that as well (the guys at Napa hated me in the end). The ones that I listed, worked perfectly. I can only push the gate about a 1/4" past where they lock out. I tried a couple of pair that when closed pushed the piston of the gas shock too far into the cylinder and almost ruined them (the guys at Napa really love when you bring 'em back like that).
Like I said, the ones listed worked perfect for me. I simple unscrewed the fittings on the end and dropped them into the factory cylinders.
I'll work on getting some pics.