3FE Charging...does this look right?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 24, 2016
Threads
6
Messages
163
Location
Japan
I have a JDM 1990 FJ80, FE with a 90 amp alternator. I am having the dim headlights at a stop light, "revving" blower fan with the blinker on, trans and voltage lights flashing with the blinker issues.

Idle speed is 610 rpm in drive with the headlights and blower on full. If I rev it a bit, to 750 rpm, the headlights are bright and there are no issues.

I think my alternator and battery were both replaced in Nov 2014. The alternator looks to be a Toyota OEM 90 amp. Battery is a Panasonic.
Photo 2017-02-13 21 50 27.webp


The below gauge is an MPGuino and voltage is direct from the battery and is grounded to the chassis. Please excuse my makeshift enclosure as I was still testing the MPGuino out.

The MPGuino reads 1 volt low.

This pic is no load in park at 2,000 rpm.
no load.webp


This pic is the blower on full (A/C off) with headlights on, in gear.
Heat headlights on in gear.webp


This pic is the blower on full (A/C off) with headlights on, in park at 2,000 RPM.
Heat headlights not in gear.webp


My question is, shouldn't the voltage at the battery be higher at 2,000 rpm?

I think I need to do some troubleshooting.

First, I am going to check the voltage at the alternator at idle and at 2,000 rpm.
If the voltage is higher at the alternator, that should mean there is corrosion, bad connections, or bad wiring. I think it can also mean a bad battery. If the voltage coming out of the alternator at idle and 2,000 rpm is only 12.5 volts, I would assume the voltage regulator or alternator is bad.

Any other suggestions? I know part of this is a bit normal for the 3FE charging system.
 
Last edited:
Just took a 5 minute break and checked...the battery voltage is 12.43 volts without the engine running. 12.43 is a bit on the low side, but should be okay. At no load idle, with the volt meter on the positive, it reads 13.2 volts. The alternator output however reads 14.7 volts. The FSM says to replace the voltage regulator if above 14.4 volts.

How am I going from 14.7 at the alternator to 13.2 at the battery? My wiring looks pretty new for a 1990. There is no visible corrosion.

Does this sound correct?

I am going to see if I can have the battery and charging system checked today.
 
Last edited:
got the system checked. It said the diodes were bad and I need a new alternator.

It makes me wonder if that was a Toyota reman. alternator on there. I think it should have lasted more than two years.
 
Last edited:
So I've been reading up on alternator failures on here. It seems the 3FE alternators don't make much power at idle. The load could be 30+ amps at idle with the headlights/taillights/brake lights on (13 amps), fuel pump (3-7 amps), blower on high (15-20 amps), ECU (.5 amps), injectors (1 amp), then add in the stereo, phone charger, blinkers, etc. I can't find an alternator performance graph for the 90 amp, but looking at similar alternators, 650 engine rpm (maybe 1300 alternator rpm?) isn't going to put out much. I'd assume at idle our alternators are good for 25 amps? (this assumes my assumptions are correct...)

I am thinking that my alternator's diodes didn't last long because the load demand is higher than what the alternator is putting out, creating too much heat? This is evident in the headlights dimming at idle. Lots of warm ups in the winter weather with that blower on high would cause a high idle load. Am I way off in my logic?

So, how can I reduce load at idle in order to try and make the diodes last longer? Leave the lights and stereo off during warm ups. LED tails/stops/blinkers should save around 3 amps. I can't do anything for the fuel pump, ECU, or injectors. I can manually turn the blower from high to low which should cut off 10 amps or so. This would bring me from an estimated 30 amps to 17 amps. HIDs may save 5 more amps, assuming they draw 4 amps running and the stock headlight bulbs are 9 amps. That would leave me at 12 amps at idle.

Thoughts? I've had a lot of caffeine today...
 
I have a 91, and my running voltage is right at 13.7 volts. Having a pretty complex audio system w/ Amps, gps, heater, lights and other things on ~might~ drop my voltage to 13.2 volts-running. My idle in gear is a rock solid 650rpm though. I think your in gear idle sounds low at 610rpm's, and at that low of an idle every rpm helps! Not sure if these have a "idle up" solenoid to kick up rpm's when certain hi draw items are switched on? Good luck!
 
Wow definately alot of caffeine I would start with making sure the battery if fully charged and swap out the alternator. Wiring as a whole is not really good on the stock 3FE but does what it is supposed to. I have replace all of my bulbs with LED and have seen some improvement in power draw. I would check all of your grounds and wires make sure everything is good there. If you were to go to a higher output alternator you are going to have to go to a higher gauge wiring to be able to handle the load.
 
I have a 91, and my running voltage is right at 13.7 volts. Having a pretty complex audio system w/ Amps, gps, heater, lights and other things on ~might~ drop my voltage to 13.2 volts-running. My idle in gear is a rock solid 650rpm though. I think your in gear idle sounds low at 610rpm's, and at that low of an idle every rpm helps! Not sure if these have a "idle up" solenoid to kick up rpm's when certain hi draw items are switched on? Good luck!

I need to check the timing and the idle...

Funny you mention the idle up. There is an idle up input into the ECU from the AC. I think there is a way to apply 12 volts into the ECU into the AC input to trick the ECU into thinking the AC was on. I thought about wiring something like that up in order to fix the low idle issue.
 
Wow definately alot of caffeine I would start with making sure the battery if fully charged and swap out the alternator. Wiring as a whole is not really good on the stock 3FE but does what it is supposed to. I have replace all of my bulbs with LED and have seen some improvement in power draw. I would check all of your grounds and wires make sure everything is good there. If you were to go to a higher output alternator you are going to have to go to a higher gauge wiring to be able to handle the load.

Yes, alternator is on order and battery will be charged up. LEDs are next. Although everyone in Japan has HIDs, I am not sure I want to get them.

No need more for amps. I use a JBL bluetooth speaker for my sound needs. I can grab it, take it to work, then take it home. It provides plenty of sound.
 
Lol, I HAD the same audio you had, until I left it in, and someone at the boat launch ramp decided they needed it worse! They do sound great.... I went back to the old way.
As far as idle up goes, you could try to just push the selector on the heater over to defrost at a stop sign, just to see if it helps any, I'm pretty sure defrost and ac both trigger the idle up. Good luck!
 
Lol, I HAD the same audio you had, until I left it in, and someone at the boat launch ramp decided they needed it worse! They do sound great.... I went back to the old way.
As far as idle up goes, you could try to just push the selector on the heater over to defrost at a stop sign, just to see if it helps any, I'm pretty sure defrost and ac both trigger the idle up. Good luck!

That sucks! I'd be pissed.

Do you have the idle control under the steering wheel??
 
That sucks! I'd be pissed.

Do you have the idle control under the steering wheel??

The US didn't come stock with the throttle cable to use that would only be a comfort fix in my opinion that is more designed for scenarios when you need more power while static like winching some people will use it as a poor mans cruise control but its not safe. Stick with what you have planned now and keep going. Hand throttle is nice to have though it is something I am going to be installing over the next 6 months of the "sprint" I am doing on my build.
 
That sucks! I'd be pissed.

Do you have the idle control under the steering wheel??

No idle control, and I don't have any problems. Even with everything I have turned "on" my volts, while at idle, never drop below 13volts. But then again my idle is right on 650rpm's, didn't you say you had an idle of 610 or something? That's why I'm thinking that if you can increase your idle, just a bit, it may help you. How? I have no idea, and I may be way off course with my thoughts!
 
The US didn't come stock with the throttle cable to use that would only be a comfort fix in my opinion that is more designed for scenarios when you need more power while static like winching some people will use it as a poor mans cruise control but its not safe. Stick with what you have planned now and keep going. Hand throttle is nice to have though it is something I am going to be installing over the next 6 months of the "sprint" I am doing on my build.

I agree with this 100%! To just "kick the idle up" with a hand throttle would only be hiding the problem, not correcting it! Like jdayment said, need to find the root of the problem. And I think your doing the right thing..... progressing thru the trouble shooting steps. I know it's a pita, I did it yesterday with my 80, I was inches away from putting a small piece of plasteek on it, and blowing it to bits! Frustrating, but the guys on here are second to none! Good luck!
 
The US didn't come stock with the throttle cable to use that would only be a comfort fix in my opinion that is more designed for scenarios when you need more power while static like winching some people will use it as a poor mans cruise control but its not safe. Stick with what you have planned now and keep going. Hand throttle is nice to have though it is something I am going to be installing over the next 6 months of the "sprint" I am doing on my build.

I was just curios, I don't plan on using it as a fix to my possibly low idle.

I will keep troubleshooting the cause. I may have time today to go check the timing and idle speed. I know my belts are older, but my Rockauto order of new belts is traveling all around the US for some reason, and not heading over here! A slipping belt won't help me. Also, the new alternator is on order.

LEDs may be ordered today too. I think if I can shave off some of the load on the alternator at idle, it should last longer.
 
Update. New alternator and two of three belts replaced. I got the wrong power steering/air pump/alternator belt. When taking the belts off, the AC belt and the inner alternator belt were loose and highly glazed over. We tested the new alternator and at first it failed for diodes. Then the guy testing it got in and watched the RPMs (needed 2,000rpm) instead of guessing the RPMs using the throttle lever. It passed when he got the RPMs high enough.

The first time he checked the old alternator, when it failed for diodes, he guessed the RPMs at the throttle lever. I am guessing that the RPMs were low and it showed bad diodes, when in fact the alternator may not have been bad.

Charging voltage is up and everything works brighter at idle. I think it was a belt issue.

I am going to take apart the alternator and have my guys at work check the diodes on the "bad" alternator. We shall see.
 
Last edited:
So, tested the rectifier and it was good. So it looks like the old alternator wasn't bad. The tech did do the test wrong. I'll keep it as a spare...

IMG_0778.webp
 
Im not electrical genius by any means. I can barley turn on a computer or spell correctly much less.... but..... I actually had the same issues over the last week. I left my headlights on for a few hours before someone at work told me. went out to start it and it was dead as a door nail. I was only pulling 3.5 volts. thought that was strange myself being that on my fj cruiser I have left my lights on for 8 hours and its started right up with no issues. and those like were my 9 inch hella freeform lights. so being that I wanted to upgrade my battery anyways i replaced it with a group 34 yellow top and my battery voltage is right on key. I trickle charged my old napa battery and it charge up fine and is holding a charge perfectly. so far im thinking that the group of battery that was on it was to big for the factory alternator. I had the same issues when I first bought my fj cruiser a few years back. after doing some research and talking to much better techs then myself I discovered that normally upgrade batteries are to big for the factory amps. so now I trickle charge my batteries once a month and now I have no more issues with them. since I have swapped my battery in my 80 series I have been holding a steady 14 volts at idle unless I have the blower on higher with everything else at idle and I may drop to 13.7 volts. just something to think about. I could be doing it all wrong and delaying the inevitable failure of my 80 alternator but my fj cruiser has been running strong with the same alternator and battery for 3 years with long winch pulls and a lot of accessories running at long time frames. I enjoy a lot of night wheeling and im not shy on lights or stereo systems. hope that helps!
 
Im not electrical genius by any means. I can barley turn on a computer or spell correctly much less.... but..... I actually had the same issues over the last week. I left my headlights on for a few hours before someone at work told me. went out to start it and it was dead as a door nail. I was only pulling 3.5 volts. thought that was strange myself being that on my fj cruiser I have left my lights on for 8 hours and its started right up with no issues. and those like were my 9 inch hella freeform lights. so being that I wanted to upgrade my battery anyways i replaced it with a group 34 yellow top and my battery voltage is right on key. I trickle charged my old napa battery and it charge up fine and is holding a charge perfectly. so far im thinking that the group of battery that was on it was to big for the factory alternator. I had the same issues when I first bought my fj cruiser a few years back. after doing some research and talking to much better techs then myself I discovered that normally upgrade batteries are to big for the factory amps. so now I trickle charge my batteries once a month and now I have no more issues with them. since I have swapped my battery in my 80 series I have been holding a steady 14 volts at idle unless I have the blower on higher with everything else at idle and I may drop to 13.7 volts. just something to think about. I could be doing it all wrong and delaying the inevitable failure of my 80 alternator but my fj cruiser has been running strong with the same alternator and battery for 3 years with long winch pulls and a lot of accessories running at long time frames. I enjoy a lot of night wheeling and im not shy on lights or stereo systems. hope that helps!

So you went with a smaller battery in your 80? That may be something to think about. Mine is acting much better right now, except the lights still dim with the blower above medium. I have HIDs and LEDs on the list to add soon. I should be able to cut a few amps with them. I also have a new flasher module that is supposed to use less power.

Now that I have an extra pulley, I am thinking about having my machinist at work shave it down a bit. The alternator is fine above 900 or so engine rpm. If the pulley is smaller, I think it will help.
 
all vehicles will put out less at idle as im sure you know. if you want more power look at Js Alternators. They offer 170 amps at 299 and a 240 amp 379. they are straight swaps so they claim with the exception of a shorter belt. they has a dual v band pullies for the dual belt set up. and it requires no plug because they have a self exciter for a regulator. these word are damn near verbatim from Js Alternators. I have read some really good reviews from them. when my alternator goes out im going to replace it with one of theirs. as far a a smaller battery the size itself is smaller yes but it puts out the same if not more power if im not correct. I believe the factory battery is a group 27 which is larger in size than the 34. I specifically got a 34-78 for the front mount points. im going to use the original battery for a starting battery and use my yellow top for all my accessories including my winch going to it because it has the front mount points. also I second the checking your grounds. I personally replaced the garbage ground that goes from the transfer case to the frame rail and added one from the trans to the frame. eventually going to replace all the factory ground with new 4 gauge or 2. maybe overkill but I know the older vehicles are very sensitive to static grounds that will cause issues with the ECU or what ever Toyota calls their control units. as far as cutting amps with led everything is a neat idea but I don't see it being that much of a difference but as I said before im no wizard haha. you should give me a parts list for all the leds and if you have had to or need to add resistors for them. being that we are dealing with the first 80s I doubt we would if you replace them in tandem. let me know what you come up with. i would be interested to see your results with your next steps in your diagnosis.
 
My numbers here are somewhat researched, but really more of a rough guess. With the blinkers on, I can probably save 10 amps by switching to LEDs. At idle, 10 amps is a lot considering I don't think our alternators put out more than 30 or so at idle.

I have a new multimeter on the way along with all of the LEDs. I will get some solid data to try and back up my rough guesses.

Not looking for an upgraded alternator at this time. Just trying to keep my headlights and heater fan from dimming/revving at idle with the blinkers on.

Once I have the LEDs installed, I'll post pics and part numbers.

Untitled.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom