Soot on the tailpipe

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 28, 2003
Threads
37
Messages
279
Location
The Buttcrack of Idaho
I have an ongoing problem with soot on the tailpipe. It has done this since I bought it three years ago but it seems to be getting worse. The funny ring on the pipe doesn't bother me, but what else could be going on. It starts and runs great. Plugs are normal colored. Today I did notice cracks in the evap. canister. I did have a horrible gas vapor smell problem this summer when it was hot. And the exhaust has always smelled "off" to me.

Help, Jay

History:
93 FZJ80
190,000 miles
Owned since 154,000
Plugs,cap,rotor, 185,000
Wires 160,000
No Fault Codes
New muffler and Cat 185,000

Symptoms:
Soot around tailpipe
Soot on pinhole before cat
Crap Mileage: 14 Highway
Less power than similar equipped 80s
Tailpipe-1.webp
Tailpipe-2.webp
 
Possibly an over rich air/fuel mixture ie: either too much fuel being injected into the cylinders, or what gets there is not burned efficiently; like bad plugs, wrong plugs,weak spark, plugged air filter, etc. Not sure if too much oil being sucked into the engine; via blow-by and/or the PCV system would cause the soot, but that is a known problem with these anyways. The funky smell from the cats can be from unburnt fuel, which can cause the cats to overheat and melt.

g
 
Thanks, gray

The 93 has a single cat. The problem was there with the original cat, straight pipes with no cat, and now with high performance shorty cat. I havn't noticed any unusual oil consumption, also the PCV was replaced at 154,000. I am on the second set of plugs now and neither removed set show anything but mild tan color.

Jay
 
The thing with the PCV system is that it sucks a lot of oil into the intake and engine, gumming up things.
But I would not think that by itself would cause the soot. I'm wondering why the first cat died? Same problem? If you haven't done this already, I would put a can of BG44K into the gas and spray a can of something like Berryman's carb cleaner into the PVC port (that is where the PCV hose goes into the throttle body, not the valve cover) This will get sucked into the throttle body and clean some of the crud out; from what I have seen on the thread, most of the crud that gets into the throttle body is from the PCV system. Does it idle well, accelerate normally, etc?

g
 
Last edited:
The thing with the PCV system is that it sucks a lot of oil into the intake and engine, gumming up things.
But I would not think that by itself would cause the soot. I'm wondering why the first cat died? Same problem? If you haven't done this already, I would put a can or two of BG44K into the gas, clean the internal engine parts with an engine flush, and spray a couple of cans of something like Berryman's carb cleaner into the PVC port (that is where the PCV hose goes into the throttle body, not the valve cover) This will get sucked into the throttle body and clean some of the crud out; from what I have seen on the thread, most of the crud that gets into the throttle body is from the PCV system. (This is, however, my standard suggestion for just about every problem, HA!) Does it idle well, accelerate normally, etc?
g

gray
The first cat died from rust and rocks, I tried pipe sections to replace it, but I couldn't stand the noise. I have neglected to clean the throttle body, that sounds like a good starting point.
Have the oxygen sensors ever been replaced? I suspect they would be worn out after 190,000 miles.

psfpilot
The O2 sensors were replaced at 185,000

Thanks for the suggestions, I'm tired of bothering with this and really don't want to ruin the new cat.

Jay
 
I am having the same problem with my 3Fe and dont even have a cat on mine (PO removed it and failed to mention to me before I bought it).
As far as I know, the O2 sensors are original. I have messed around with the MAF adjustment...seems that is when I started noticing it...so Im guessing it might just be a to rich of fuel/air mixture...

Also noticed my gas mileage dropped about .5 - 1mpg...but I have more HP out of my 3Fe...
 
I am having the same problem with my 3Fe and dont even have a cat on mine (PO removed it and failed to mention to me before I bought it).
As far as I know, the O2 sensors are original. I have messed around with the MAF adjustment...seems that is when I started noticing it...so Im guessing it might just be a to rich of fuel/air mixture...

Also noticed my gas mileage dropped about .5 - 1mpg...but I have more HP out of my 3Fe...

So only two of us have had this problem.

Jay
 
So only two of us have had this problem.

Jay

Clean out the PCV system and throttle body; do not be timid here; a few large cans through all the intake ports, not a few squirts. Just keep it running by working the throttle with your other hand. There are many threads about adding a "catch can" in the PCV system to catch oil that is sucked into the intake; this is the major cause of the crud inside the intake.

If you still have the problem, it may be worth it to take it to a good honest mechanic ( :lol: ) and ask him to check it out. ie: by then you will have done most everything you can do without the special diagnostic tools needed.

Almost forgot; you mentioned a pinhole before the cat? Are you saying that the pipe is rusted through, before the cat?

g
 
Last edited:
Three - But I haven't fixed it so I"m waiting to see how you fix it so I can copy :)

Man, first you call dibs on the battery tray before I can, now you let me ask the dumb questions and wait for the advice. Oh wait, thats how mud works all the time.
corkysm20.gif


So far I'm thinking heavy cleaning on the intake, and then look at turbocruisers oil catch methods.

Any other ideas?

Jay
 
Bump! I assume you don't do a lot of short rides (less than 10 minutes) with your truck since you are Idaho. If you do, maybe the truck doesn't have enough time to warm up and thus burns rich in fuel most of the time like at start up. This would account for the burning rich theory and the black soot. I have a 94 but it doesn't have that much soot.
 
Lots of soot here too on a 95. Original cats and O2 sensors at 210k :). ive got a pin hole in the resonator that shows soot at this location too. maybe moisture, possibly oil, sprayed from tailpipe to the bumper. Im thinking catch can and tb/maf cleaning as well. but then again my taco has the same thing???
 
Bump! I assume you don't do a lot of short rides (less than 10 minutes) with your truck since you are Idaho. If you do, maybe the truck doesn't have enough time to warm up and thus burns rich in fuel most of the time like at start up. This would account for the burning rich theory and the black soot. I have a 94 but it doesn't have that much soot.

Sorry for ignoring this thread, I just got busy.

My most common trip is 45 miles of interstate 70 mph plus, so I don't think it's cold idle related.

Lots of soot here too on a 95. Original cats and O2 sensors at 210k :). ive got a pin hole in the resonator that shows soot at this location too. maybe moisture, possibly oil, sprayed from tailpipe to the bumper. Im thinking catch can and tb/maf cleaning as well. but then again my taco has the same thing???

All things are pointing to running rich, I just can't find a competent mechanic to diagnose it.

Thanks, Jay
 
Has there been any change in mileage?
If it starts and runs great, and the plugs are normal why do you suspect a rich condition?
Are you burning any oil?
Any smoke on startup?
Soot in the tail pipe is a fairly normal byproduct of combustion, if everything else looks good, I don't think I would worry about it.
 
Some soot is normal. Yours does not look exessive to me.
 
I have soot on my tailpipe now and today while leaving work I put the cruiser in reverse and parked to check for any leaks where I was parking and I was glad to see that there were no leaks where the cruiser was parked! I did notice though that there was black liquid that sprayed out from the tailpipe and crated this huge splatter of black liquid like someone took a fountain pen and shook the pen so the ink would come out!
 
You guys do realize that these pigs dump 18 tons of soot per week into the air, that is if you only drive them 10 miles a day or so- adjust as necessary for real-world driving. Some of that stuff has to stick to the tailpipe. I wouldn't be too concerned.

-Spike
 
Back
Top Bottom