P401 or Seppuku

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 10, 2005
Threads
45
Messages
1,448
Seppuku, also known as hara-kiri, is what I am now considering.

My MIL went off, exactly 415 miles after replacing a short piece of
hose from the intake to the top of the EGR. To recap, I
have replaced all components, except temp sensor, cleaned everything, a lot, and checked all hose connections. It initially
stayed off for 2500 miles after the new parts were installed,
then came back; replaced one the rubber EGR vacuum hose
which was dried out, no good.

The last hose replaced, 8 inches of small vacuum hose to the top of the EGR, seemed to have finally fixed it but back it came after 415 miles, the dreaded orange light of death.

I do have a new temp sensor that I was about to return for credit,
but maybe I will now put it in, what the heck.

Anyone have any new ideas, or a sharp knife?

g
 
I've got some "Ginsu" knives still and I would be more than happy to chop your head off after you do cut your stomach open, in the traditional manner. :D

No good (or any) suggestions here.

Good luck fixing it, but don't take your own life.;)

Mot :hillbilly:
 
Addendum to post;

I think someone mentioned this before; asking it another way around;

How often does a short in the harness cause a P401, and how difficult (or easy) is it to trace that down?

About a year and a half ago, I had a short in my harness (near the firewall/EGR pipe) that was somehow affecting the circuit to one of the fuel injectors, which actually caused my port installed alarm to shut down the vehicle, or so they told me. The mechanic to disable the alarm system and fix the short to get it going.

Wondering if this repeated P401 is due to the harness; ie: one bad wire, many bad wires??

Can someone who is good at electical stuff track this down if it were a short??

I would rather not unwrap my tanto just yet.

G
 
I've got some "Ginsu" knives still and I would be more than happy to chop your head off after you do cut your stomach open, in the traditional manner. :D

No good (or any) suggestions here.

Good luck fixing it, but don't take your own life.;)

Mot :hillbilly:

Actually, I am not surprised to find volunteers who would help
get rid of me.;p:crybaby::D
 
Good Luck

Good Luck with P401. I've been fighting it part-time for 6 years now.

I'm going after the EGR VSV this weekend. Maybe I'll get lucky...
 
Did you replace the EGR VSV? That's a very common cause in the persistant cases that don't respond to cleaning the egr pipe or the modulator.
 
Did you replace the EGR VSV? That's a very common cause in the persistant cases that don't respond to cleaning the egr pipe or the modulator.

Yes, everything;

First clean clean clean; stayed off for around 500 miles, clean clean clean again, stayed off for a couple hundred miles; then it came back and would not go away.

Then VSV, came right back.

Then EGR and Vac Modulator only 1500 miles and one week after VSV replacment; Mil stayed off for 2500 miles, then came back.

Then more diagnoses, dealer thought it was a temp sensor,
but I was not convinced. So held off on the temp sensor, but got one.

Then I found some cracked insulation on the connector wires
that go to VSV, so cleaned them and coated them with liquid
wire insulation. No difference; code came back.

Then replaced the short piece of vac hose that goes from the VSV intake manifold port to the top of the EGR; Mil stayed off
and I thought that I had fixed it.

Mil stayed off for 415 miles, then came on today; a wet rainy day.
It has been raining for a few days straight (?moisture on bad wires)

Only part not replaced is the temp sensor, when I checked it
a few weeks ago, I got 39kohms, the dealer said he got 75kohms;
the FSM says you should get 4 kphms or less; that is when
I thought I may have misread the reading; ie: 3.9, not 39.

I guess between the two of us, one may be right, meaning
the temp sensor is the culprit.

Anyone ever trace the P401 to a bad harness?

How hard would it be to do that?

G
 
Went back and read all previous posts; first thing to do will be the check the circuits;
may need some help, but makes sense to do that first.

I am thinking that it is not a failed component; either a bad vacuum connection
or an electrical problem.

We will see, or not.

g
 
I'm on a roll tonight, too much Vault/caffeine.

Just checked my EGR temp sensor ohm reading; but could not get a reading; the digital readout just displayed a 1 on the far left hand corner no matter what range I put the dial at??
Turned it off, back on, switch the dial, etc.,etc
Tried everthing, reversing the red and black probes, recheck, recheck, recheck; still just a 1.

I know the multi reader was working as I also immediately checked the harness side of the connector
for the temp sensor, and got 5 volts, right where it should be.

I also checked the connector at the short VSV harness section, and got 36 on the 200 ohm dial range,
or .03 when on the 20K ohm range.

Is that correct? Could not find it in the FSM, but will look again

The upside (harness side) of the VSV circuit I also got around 4 volts.

Any thoughts on my temp sensor?

G
 
Have you measured the new one?

-B-

Forgot that little step:doh: Thought about as I sat here writing the post;
will do that tomorrow when all three
components needed are in the same place; ie: me, the new temp sensor, and the mulitmeter;)

g
 
Ok,
Checked the FSM for the VSV continuity;
It says at 68 degrees F the ohm reading of the VSV should be 30-34 ohms (not k ohms).

I got a reading of 36 ohms, but the engine had been running, so was easily over 100 degrees
I would guess.

It was however not a direct reading, I took the reading (as suggested by I forgot) via
the short harness section that runs to the VSV; so, that one foot of wiring could
add something to the ohm reading, correct??

Seems like it should be a lower number if warmer, but not sure how much, and not sure
of the accuracy of the cheapo multimeter, or how much the wiring would add.

Either way, seems like the VSV is probably close to specs.

Next I will recheck the old temp sensor with another multimeter, and at the same time
check the new sensor; however, it will be cold, so the reading will be way up there; at least
it will check on my technique and the multimeter.

G
 
Oh crap.. I just got this code a couple of days ago... looks like I got some work ahead of me!!

Just a quick Q:

How did you go about cleaning things??

Thanks and good luck!
 
Oh crap.. I just got this code a couple of days ago... looks like I got some work ahead of me!!

Just a quick Q:

How did you go about cleaning things??

Thanks and good luck!

Everyone has their own "magic milk" or secret potion to clean
an intake; the only absolute method I'ver learned from reading the posts is to remove the intake and soak it overnight and then scrub it.

While it is out, you can replace the VSV and the hoses.

OR, you can tempt fate and try the easy way.

I removed the temp sensor; unhook it first from it's connector,
then remove it from the intake; then probe through that opening
toward the EGR to get an idea of how much carbon you've got.

Then spray a ton of Throttle body cleaner into that port/opening;
both while engine running and not.

With the engine running, it will get sucked via the same passageway
as the EGR gases.
The engine will die if you do not keep the rpms up by pushing
on the throttle with your free hand.

Next spray a ton of your favorite intake cleaner through every vacuum port that goes into the intake that you can get off; but most important are the little ports in the front of the throttle body and the PCV port; that is where all the oil gets sucked in.

Be sure to clean the temp sensor tip also when it is off.

There is a foaming intake cleaner on the market I like; called MIGHTY brand;
you have to look for it (google it) sometimes tires stores sell it;
you can spray that in the temp sensor port and let it sit for 15 minutes, then run the engine and even spray more cleaner;
whatever.
They also make a super strength intake cleaner kit; comes in a box for about 39-49$; it will make you sick and wheeze if you breath the smoke that comes out the tailpipe, so don't;
do it when there is a strong breeze blowing away from where you are standing. Or, wear a chemical mask good for nitrogen oxides.

Of course, check all vacuum hoses; I have learned that even if
they look good, if they are hard, they do not seal as well once
they have been taken off a few times; better to replace them
if they do not stick real well on their pipes/nipples.

CAUTION CAUTION:
DO NOT spray cleaner into the little port/pipe that sticks
up on the back of the intake; the one that connects up to the top
of the EGR valve via a short 7-8 inch piece of vacuum hose;
this little port can get clogged, but it goes into the VSV valve
via the manifold, internally; it is NOT a straight shot into
the manifold as you might think.

You MUST first reach under the manifold, feel around for a short section of hose that goes from the VSV into the underside of the manifold and disconnect it first;

If you do not, you will drown the VSV with cleaner,probably killing it,
if it is not dead already; Lesson learned the hard way.

If you are not sure, get an FSM and check out the diagram of
the VSV hoses to get your bearings.

That is enough for now, you will be back; just read the 2000 posts
on P401.

Good luck and get a large bottle of antacids and another of Motrin.:D

G
 
Just a quick note to add to the above:

If you wanna access the VSV w/o removing the intake, try this:
-remove the upper intake support brace completely (two bolts, top and bottom)
-remove the two bolts that hold the VSV valve to the underside of the intake. The Aft 12mm socket bolt can be removed by laying on the ground and using two LONG extensions.
-the Front bolt is removed by sticking your hand through the hole (created by removing the brace) and a ratcheting wrench.

Once you remove the bracket that holds the VSV, you can go about your troubleshooting business.

The picture below will help you visualize. Picture was taken from the passenger fender, looking toward the driver side. The front of the engine is to the right. The red circle is the VSV and the two bolts for the VSV bracket mentioned above. Pay attention to how the hoses are run as I had these backwards. Even after I fixed the hoses I still got a 401 so the search continues :crybaby:

vsv.jpg


Cheers.
 
to alia 176:
nice photo, shows how everything sits, including where the EGR-VSV hose/port goes through the manifold.
Is this from a right hand drive; or was the photo reversed ie: in photoshop??

I was too weak (willed) and did not attempt to take mine off; took it to a dealer for
just the VSV; geez $300 just for labor, and he did it the quick way himself. On the other hand,
to do it by the book, they charge something like 700 labor, then the parts.
Next time, I'll do it myself.

Back to the ohm reading questions; anyone out there have an idea why my multimeter stayed on
1 (displayed to the far left), when checking my temp sensor??

g
 
Is this from a right hand drive; or was the photo reversed ie: in photoshop??

The picture below will help you visualize. Picture was taken from the passenger fender, looking toward the driver side.

Back to the ohm reading questions; anyone out there have an idea why my multimeter stayed on 1 (displayed to the far left), when checking my temp sensor??

User error?

-B-
 
Back to the ohm reading questions; anyone out there have an idea why my multimeter stayed on
1 (displayed to the far left), when checking my temp sensor??

g

The 1. means "out of range".

Good multimeter tutorial. Click on the resistance portion.

http://www.ladyada.net/library/metertut/



Just to clarify, when you cleaned did you remove the TB or just spray stuff in all the ports?
 
MoJ,
I did not remove my intake; over a year, I had sprayed a ton of mostly Valvoline's Throttle Body cleaner into the PCV, Brake booster, breather, and temp sensor ports; later on I sprayed it into
the little ports on the front of the throttle body. Also, a few cans directly into the intake and the butterfly
valve; All together at least 10 cans of cleaner over a year.

When the P401 came back, I went out and found the foaming MIGHTY brand intake cleaner and
their industrial strength cleaner as well; most was sucked in via the temp sensor port
(with the temp sensor out). The foaming stuff is meant to sit for sometime to soften up any crud.

The advantage here is that the temp sensor is directly across from the EGR port, so you can see and feel if it is plugged; by spraying through here, the cleaner will get sucked via the same route the EGR gases and carbon go. Seems to make sense to me.

Later, when I had the EGR off, the port was clean as a whistle.

G
 
OK,
The 1 on the multimeter meant out of range, but I had switched to multiple ranges
ie: 2K, 20K, 2000K etc. Still a 1; the FSM says when the temp sensor is hot, it should read around 4K ohms, I do not recall the highest setting I tried.

Will do it again today, with a different multimeter (?autoranging for dummies) and check
the new temp sensor at the same time.

More to follow

g
 
Back
Top Bottom