i have never had an issue with any of mine but those that sell the replacement kits don't like them. USUALLY the only time they fail is if the idiot that takes them apart doesn't read the manual and trys to slam them back on without retaining the tiny brushes back out of the way...
i have yet to see them fail under normal off road use.
of course the other claim is the elec are only held on by 4 bolts instead of the old 6 bolt pattern... problem is the newer are actually held on by 10 bolts, not 6... sales pitch still flows easily from those that want to make money.
now, if someone just doesn't like electronics then i can see ditching the elec hubs ... but i like them.but then i also like Warn manual, Asian manual... the only ones i don't like are the auto hubs...i have had a couple of them let go over the decades...