Lost 2qts of oil in 1,000 miles... Just switched to Synth..

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 17, 2005
Threads
74
Messages
571
Location
Tucson, AZ
What's up with this? I was driving today after switching to Rotella Synthetic about 1,000 miles ago and the oil light comes on. So I check the oil and I'm 2 qts low? I don't get it at all, most people talk of using less oil after switching, is this just a first time thing or what? It's a 1996 that had 109k on it when I switched.
 
Don't switch back just yet. Unless you can find a "huge" and obvious leak, then give the seal swelling agents time to do their work.

This is a good subject to run a search on also. You can get an idea of what others have experienced.
 
This is a good subject to run a search on also. You can get an idea of what others have experienced.

Well, I did my searching before switching.. I haven't seen any signs of a leak honestly so I don't know what it is. I'll just keep an eye on it and see what happens I guess.. Has anybody had the same issue?
 
Judging from your other rigs, I'm assuming you personally changed the oil and put 8 quarts in? Very often people who have others change their oil later find the truck low and it's difficult to know what to say as they really don't have true knowledge it was filled properly.

Also, how's your PCV valve?

DougM
 
Judging from your other rigs, I'm assuming you personally changed the oil and put 8 quarts in? Very often people who have others change their oil later find the truck low and it's difficult to know what to say as they really don't have true knowledge it was filled properly.

Also, how's your PCV valve?

I filled it to what I thought was almost too much. I have the small filter and added almost two containers of Rotella so that's almost 2 gallons. I kept adding until the dipstick was reading full for sure.

Not sure about the PVC though.

What weight oil? What oil was in it before? How much oil did it use before?

I think the Rotella is what 5-40 if I'm not mistaken. No clue what was in it before as this was the first change I've done. Didn't seem to use any prior. I also couldn't find one leak under the Cruiser and it's in the same spot every night. In fact sometimes we don't even drive for 2 or 3 days in a row. We only put on maybe 6,000-7,000 a year..
 
I tried M1 at ~200k - constantly topping off - wasnt dripping leaking or whatever - got fed up enough that I went back to dino at ~220k

go back to dino and oil consumption greatly reduced

I think in my case I need a little bit of burnt carbon on the cylinder walls or valve stems to seal things up

being able to buy the big 5 quart jugs of dino for the same price as a single quart of syn is nice too
 
I dont know what to say, but i experienced the same thing right after switching to mobil 1. I then did an oil change after about 4 k and it hasnt gone down since (been about 2k now).

Cant really explain it, but it seems to be the same thing happening to you.

Weird thing was, when i drained the oil, i measure how much came out and it was right @ 8 quarts!
 
I would just top it off and watch it for the next bit of time each time you fill up the truck. Checking the oil and coolant and looking under the hood during fill ups gives me something to do while I am waiting for the fuel to go in. This way by toping it off when warm you have the correct amount. When changing over to syn oil you will be cleaning up stuff in the engine and some may slip more until things are clean. later robbie
 
This exact same thing happened to me when I switched to Schaeffer's 15W-40 synthetic blend. Cured me of not checking my oil level every week!

It settled down after the first OCI. I've got 1,000 miles on the current batch of Schaeffer's and it has not dropped at all.
 
I also experienced the same thing when swithching to Mobil 1 5w-30, not as drastic though. Lost about a quart in the first 3000 miles and it hasn't dropped since.
 
Hmmm, i wonder why this happens. Kind of odd huh?
 
Okay, so I'll just keep an eye on it. Seems sortta like paying dues to the oil gods for switching or something. Thanks a lot for the tips and I will keep you all posted.
 
To put it simply, this just happens sometimes. When I switched my wife's BMW over to Mobil 1 0w-40, it ate up a quart in 500 miles, then another quart in 750 miles. Since then consumption has leveled back out at about 1 quart every 4000-5000 miles. Give it a bit of time.
 
I have yet to hear an explanation that makes any sense to me...and I can't come up with one of my own, either.
 
synthetic will clean out your engine and open up space you didn't have before. I onced quickly clogged up 3 oil filters before the engine was cleaned out of all the petroleum oil deposits. I prefer to have the syn oil cleaner clean the engine but if you use a crankcase cleaner prior to switching to sythetic you can avoid a lot of the usage issues that normally occur with the first fill when switching to synthetic. You will burn it faster at first as the engine is cleaning itself.
I use Amsoil 10W40 and don't have any usage issues. Amsoil also makes a good engine flush to ready your engine for synthetic.
You should be fine with your next syn oil and filter change. Usage should drop off.

Having said all that, using 2 quarts in a 1,000 miles...I would be concerned too. After the next fill with syn, check your level after a couple of days, top it off and then monitor the level every 500 miles or so.

Also, my oil indicator light comes on all the time and seems to have nothing to do with oil level.
 
rdye said:
synthetic will clean out your engine and open up space you didn't have before. I onced quickly clogged up 3 oil filters before the engine was cleaned out of all the petroleum oil deposits.


My engine was on Mobil 1 prior to losing oil with the Schaeffer's. Also did a double AutoRx treatment before the switch. No gunk in there...

Even if you did clog a filter, that gunk merely displaced oil out of the filter and into the crankcase.

If the level of a supposedly closed system drops, it is because something came out...not merely went somewhere else in the closed system.
 
Back
Top Bottom