I understand the logic of using just the gasket - it's the way the engine came. But when I checked my block's flatness there's a measurable deviation using a gigantic guage that spans the entire block. It's minor. It's easily within tolerance and every 80 engine, indeed every production engine out there has deviations. But it's there and I know that using a product like this will provide more even pressure across the entire gasket than without it.
I can't see it adding high spots because it goes on as a viscous fluid that will easily flow under the pressure of a head's clamping force. This isn't a product that goes on and dries, then is finished flat before applying the gasket. I saw those and would be concerned about that issue. It is also the good stuff that is anaerobic so it will cure in the absence of air.
By providing more even pressure, it helps the head, gasket, and block behave more as one unit. Without it, the block will have greater clamping pressure at the front and rear and the block's measurable lower center (no "spot", but more an even curve) surface will have less pressure. What does this mean? Dunno. Would the new gasket I'm installing last 250,000 miles without the adhesive and 400,000 with it? Dunno.
I'm not the slightest concerned about the block being acceptably flat - this is well within tolerance but once you measure it your mind won't put it away. The head has also been measured by a pro and it's extremely flat. I just want this work to last as long as is possible and there's considerable evidence a quality sealant will help. I don't see a downside.
If one of you had cited some work where a sealant was used and it failed or reacted chemically with the gasket, etc - done. Not going to use it.
Another consideration is that the block surface does have some very minor surface imperfections uniformly on its surface. These are the faint impressions of the 'tits' on the metal component of the original factory gasket that apparently are designed to grip the head and block. Over time, the movement of the head/block caused these tits to make faint impressions that fairly heavy sanding took most out. But they're still faintly there and I'm not going to pull the block and invest another $300 in having the block decked (not to mention the work to pull and reinstall it) over something that's normal. These marks are normal and I'm told the new gasket sealing material will handle it no problem.
When the engine was built at the factory they weren't there and so the gasket was more than adequate. So now that these imperfections are there, is the factory gasket less than adequate and is it common in the 'replace a head gasket on an engine with 140,000' way of thinking that the engine will need a rebuild anyhow when the gasket fails earlier due to this normal aspect of block wear/aging? Maybe that's a good way of looking at it on a domestic V8, but on a Cruiser the engine STILL won't need a rebuild at 300,000 (I know several untouched 80 engines over 300k). On this one, I can still see the undisturbed pattern of cross hatching on the cylinder walls from when it was built. So, if I can assist the sealing and have the gasket last until the engine's got 400k on it or more, why not?
I'm starting to get very long winded on this, but I don't see a downside. The race shop says it helps sealing and there's no downside. They don't use it on their engines because they strictly deal in brand new open checkbook stuff that's going to be used at max HP. You can't get in the door to buy an engine unless you've got a check for about $30,000. But the owner says he'd definitely use it for an ordinary engine being fitted with a new head gasket. He nodded his head more vigorously when I told him we tow heavy and there are times I'm going to be at wide open throttle for up to 3 minutes. So based upon all that new information what do you guys think? Gimme a downside here.
Thanks,
DougM