Fascinating dissection of 1FZ coolant/HG problem

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 27, 2003
Threads
182
Messages
4,622
Location
Socal
This is a very detailed letter that I found very interesting and seems like a very educated opinion. Long but worth the read
Second Opinion: Reader's Letter-- bitumen in oil sludge in Toyota Land Cruiser
*********************************************************
I wish I had stumbled across your brilliantly informative site much earlier. However, I have been carefully studying the failure of my 1997 LandCruiser engine (135,000 Klms/around 85,000miles) for over a year and I have derived information that I trust you'll find useful, even though it is at odds with some of the underlying assumptions of your work on "sludge". By the way, in parlance I am more accustomed to and from my experience pre-PCV systems and detergent/dispersancy factors in motor oils, "sludge" is a combination of soot (from blow by) and moisture and it gathers in the sump as grey to black muck that can be readily washed out with kerosene. It is nothing like the material that accumulated in my engine.

The material that caused my engine to fail proved to be "Bitumen" (yep, the type of material that road surfaces are made from) and definitely not sludge in the my traditionally understood sense.

It was not formed through chemical interactions and was not caused by poor maintenance. It had nothing to do with ash content, soot, or moisture. Moreover it formed from pyrolization of the organic fractions remaining in the base oil from the refining process.

The oil mist generated by the moving parts smoked off on contact with excessively hot surfaces within the crankcase and rose within the engine internals to condense as bitumen on cooler internal surfaces (e.g. cam cover and timing chain cover, and that which passed through the PCV valve condensed on the inner surfaces of the inlet manifold and that found its way down to coke up the inlet valves). It had nothing to do with the efficacy of the PCV system or any other contaminants.

One of the tests I did with thermo couples showed that a thin film of the oil I was using will smoke off a 140 degrees Celsius metal surface. (This is not the same as Flash Point). Bearing in mind that the usual coolant mix under pressurization can reach more than 130 degrees Celsius without boiling, it doesn't take much for the internals of the crankcase to exceed 140 Degrees under some operating conditions if the cooling system and temperature sensing system isn't up to the job and allows heat soak build up without temp gauge indication.

As it turns out, the evidence overwhelmingly and irrefutably shows that the block has been operating at excessive temperatures because the cooling system cannot transfer the full potential heat load up via the cylinder head through the thermostat and radiator for cooling.

The mass and surface areas of the aluminium cylinder head, cam cover and inlet manifold do a magnificent job of dissipating the heat they receive so the thermostat and bypass system stay nicely in equilibrium. Accordingly, the temperature sensing system gauge never varies from central despite the raging heat soak accumulation in the block below. Ergo, everything seems rosy to the driver and yet inside the engine can be dense clouds of smoke rising to condense as bitumen.

It didn't take me long to find that this seems to be a widely present phenomena in a a range of manufacturers' engines (but not all).

Based on the evidence, faulty cooling system design and manufacture is key to the problem as it affected me. And I reckon like problems underpin the scourge of so called "sludge" affecting many engine types.

In mine,

a. Coolant flow is severely restricted by inadequate porting through the head gasket. The sum of the areas of all of the gasket flow ports is less than the area of the pump output throat. Furthermore, the surface friction effect of all of the small holes through the gasket compared to that of the pump output throat, is about 4:1 against the flow. Hence the action of the pump is severely hampered and cavitation is inevitable (plenty of physical evidence of cavitation). and also;

b. the outflow ducting from the pump and its interface with the port into the block, have a number of significant sharp edge protrusions interfering with the path of the coolant flow. Cavitation and major bubble formation is thus further exacerbated.

To make matters worse, the occurrence of bitumen is cumulative and cannot be removed by any amount of routine servicing or flushing without removal of the sump.

The problem here is defective design. The sump drain plug is positioned well above the lowest point. Thus the sump cannot be properly drained. Interestingly, the oil; uptake draws right from the very bottom of the sump (witness marks on the bottom of the sump and careful measurements prove this to be the case. So when heated, the bitumen accumulation is circulated through the lubricating system.

Mine failed because varnish from the bitumen set around the cam followers so that when I went to start it from cold, crunch clack clack clack whir whir and cam shafts were damaged, cam cogs, chain and guides were mangled.

Sorry this is so long. There is plenty more, like with hindsight how to detect the onset and prevent failure occurring. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.

By the way, on rebuild, I had the gasket calibrated to overcome the restriction problem and the surface friction effect: Also, I spent a little time smoothing the flow path for the coolant and I repositioned the sump drain and shaped the bottom so that every last drop can be drained at any reasonable vehicle angle. Bitumen will never again be a problem in my engine.

I have also introduced a thermocouple permanently into the sump to monitor sump oil temperature. Oil temp now runs between 85 and 87 Degrees Celsius and peaks at 94 Degrees Celsius under heavy load climbing.
Oil company representatives had previously told me that Toyota LandCruiser sump temperatures ran normally at 100 Degrees Celsius plus. Proof is in the pudding for me and I am very happy indeed with the results of my study and work.

Kind regards,

Roy Edgar in Canberra, Australia "



More details about the research

Norris asked several questions of Mr. Edgar, whose response was:

"Norris, To your questions thus far:

I have religiously used Castrol GTX III, a 15 - 40 job. Oil and filter changed regularly at around 4,500 Klms. And, given the fine condition of the friction surfaces throughout, I am thoroughly impressed with the way it performed as a lubricant under such relatively extreme operating conditions and despite the bitumen load that accumulated.

When my engine first failed, I immediately got Castrol involved because I felt strongly that the oil had failed to do its cleaning job. I must say, Castrol were responsive and immediately on the job and gave assurances that if their oil was at fault then they would promptly fix it and pick up all costs and my expenses.

But when I had the engine in bits on my work bench and was able to study the problem in its entirety, I absolutely ruled out any fault in the oil as being the cause of the bitumen accumulation and the failure.

I did however, write to Toyota and suggest that the specification they gave for engine lubricants seemed questionable. Clearly no engine sold to the public for motoring purposes should generate bitumen or any other potentially damaging contaminant in its approved lubricant simply by being operated within its approved operating range and servicing cycle. If it does, then there has to be a mismatch: either the oil isn't up to its advertised specifications (in this case it certainly was up to spec) or, the manufacturer has under specified the lubricant requirements.

Stating the obvious; in normal operating, the engine gets too hot for oils that are specified for its use. There were several external markers that overwhelmingly corroborate this finding. Taking the obvious a step further, the reason it gets so hot is a design and production engineering issue.

-- Roy Edgar "
 
Last edited:
I may be under-reacting but, the use of synthetic oil and PCV Catch Can eliminates this problem totally. Seems like the guy took the totally wrong approach to fixing this effect; instead of using oil that will tolerate the temps much better without smoking or sooting and using a catch can to filter those particulates out of the PCV system, he "equalizes" the flow of the Head Gasket by boring out those passages. My understanding is that those are actually calculated by Mr. T to specifically slow the flow of coolant through the head for heat transfer purposes ... its kinda like taking the thermostat out of your cooling system if you think about it ... sure, there's more flow but does the coolant have the time to transfer the heat in that area? The reason removing the thermostat ultimately tends to make the motor run hotter is the coolant does not get to stay throughout the radiator long enough to transfer the heat out through the tubes and fins. I say use synthetic oil, keep the vehicle well maintained and well tuned and put a catch can on it and call it good. Strange for someone like me to say, but this guy has over-thought the problem and picked the wrong solutions if'n ya ask me! :cheers:
 
interesting to read and the guy seems to know quite a bit about this, at least way more than I do. But seems a bit fixated on bitumen evils.

One issue came to mind: he seems to be talking about failure due to bitumen deposits on cam followers, not the usual HG failure. How common is the former? Also seems to ascribe the no-motion temp gauge to thermal design not to the gauge quirks.
 
its kinda like taking the thermostat out of your cooling system if you think about it ... sure, there's more flow but does the coolant have the time to transfer the heat in that area? The reason removing the thermostat ultimately tends to make the motor run hotter is the coolant does not get to stay throughout the radiator long enough to transfer the heat out through the tubes and fins.

Don't want to get this discussion off track, but what I've quoted above is a complete myth as far as the basic physics involved.

Yes, I've heard that certain vehicles will overheat with the t-stat removed; that would have to be due to reduced back pressure causing reduced flow, or some other explanation.

Theoretically speaking, better flow means better cooling, period.

Curtis

Oh, and I agree with you that boring out the HG coolant passages was a bad idea, simply because it changes the flow rates between different passages, not because it's all just "too restricted".
 
Don't want to get this discussion off track, but what I've quoted above is a complete myth as far as the basic physics involved.

Yes, I've heard that certain vehicles will overheat with the t-stat removed; that would have to be due to reduced back pressure causing reduced flow, or some other explanation.

Theoretically speaking, better flow means better cooling, period.

Curtis

Oh, and I agree with you that boring out the HG coolant passages was a bad idea, simply because it changes the flow rates between different passages, not because it's all just "too restricted".

What did you quote above?
 
In the same post; post #4.

Guess I should have just said, "what I quoted".

Ohh, I see, yer saying that what you quoted, meaning my quote, was wrong. Okay, please prove that cause if I've been wrong with this all along I'd sincerely like to learn. Reduced backpressure wont really cause reduced flow in this application at least up to the point of cavitation and I have heard over and over that if the coolant doesn't stay in the radiator long enough, as in full out flow with no restriction from the thermostat (even an "open" thermostat is only allowing the system to run at a % of 100%) then there isn't enough time to effectively transfer the heat first to the coolant ( as in block and head ) then to the air (as in rad). Again, I'd sincerely like to learn more about this but yer gonna have to do better than "or some other explanation" to help me here. Thanks. :cheers:
 
Again, I'd sincerely like to learn more about this but yer gonna have to do better than "or some other explanation" to help me here. Thanks. :cheers:

From: Cooling System Basics for Spark Ignition Engines
SuperFlow Advanced Engine Technology Conference, December 7, 1992


"Higher coolant flow will ALWAYS result in higher heat transfer. Coolant cannot
absorb heat after it reaches it's pressure corrected vapor point. Furthermore, coolant absorbs heat at a progressively slower rate as it approaches this point."
 
From: Cooling System Basics for Spark Ignition Engines
SuperFlow Advanced Engine Technology Conference, December 7, 1992


"Higher coolant flow will ALWAYS result in higher heat transfer. Coolant cannot
absorb heat after it reaches it's pressure corrected vapor point. Furthermore, coolant absorbs heat at a progressively slower rate as it approaches this point."

Wow, that was truly a fascinating read. I guess I got "mythbusted". With all that in mind, I'm still wondering why removing the thermostat on so many vehicles causes it to run hotter? I'm also still wondering whether "equalizing" the HG coolant flow with the head's full potential flow as the article writer suggests is the right thing to do? This is truly one of those "universal" teachings I got from countless carfanatics that apparently is alltogether wrong! I'm sorta shocked actually. Anyways, thanks for the edumacation. :cheers:
 
Wow, that was truly a fascinating read. I guess I got "mythbusted". With all that in mind, I'm still wondering why removing the thermostat on so many vehicles causes it to run hotter? I'm also still wondering whether "equalizing" the HG coolant flow with the head's full potential flow as the article writer suggests is the right thing to do? This is truly one of those "universal" teachings I got from countless carfanatics that apparently is alltogether wrong! I'm sorta shocked actually. Anyways, thanks for the edumacation. :cheers:

I honestly have no idea why removing the t-stat can cause some vehicles to run hotter; I just know that it can't be from the myth that gets repeated so often and that you so nicely busted.

Cheers :),

Curtis
 
I honestly have no idea why removing the t-stat can cause some vehicles to run hotter; I just know that it can't be from the myth that gets repeated so often and that you so nicely busted.

Cheers :),

Curtis

Thanks, but, I think it busted me ... still ... learning like this is always fun! :cheers:
 
Not to put too fine a point on it, but Roy Edgar is simply wrong. Just wrong. It's a ludicrously speculative post that makes huge (and wrong) leaps of faith.

It would be a waste of time to refute so much of that post. I'll point out one rather obvious leap of faith. He's claiming an accumulation of grundge around the cam buckets (he calls them 'followers') caused the camshafts to be unable to turn one day when he started it, which caused so much force the cam gears and chain were broken/damaged as they turned against the jammed cam buckets. Do the logic test on that with me. Picture it in your mind. The cam lobes are levers that are about 2 inches long and solid steel. Solid, high carbon high grade forged steel with a hardened finish. They're so strong it defies description here in terms of the force they can put down on a cam bucket as they begin to turn and a cam lobe pushes down on a cam bucket. You turn an engine over and that cam lobe is moving that cam bucket down - period. They're so strong that if a valve is being pushed open and the valve hits the piston coming up - that cam bucket is STILL going to get pushed down and the valve it is pushing on is going to bend or go through the top of the piston. The force pushing down on a cam bucket is not gentle "if you feel like moving this morning, please do" force.

So, we're talking about serious strength and power here. And Roy's contention is that a ring of grundge that had been accumulating overcame that? It somehow siezed up the cam bucket one morning when he went to start the truck? Absolute and total rubbish.

The whole cooling system thing is hogwash as well. In any modern engine you will find casting edges, ports not lined up perfectly, etc so cleaning them up was nice but did not cause a measurable change in the cooling efficiency of his engine. He quotes temperatures as though HE lowered them when he has no BEFORE temperatures to compare to his AFTER temperatures. Conclusion? The temps he's now crowing about are likely the exact temps his engine was operating at before his changes - plus or minus a meaningless degree or two - the temps Toyota designed it to operate at. Note that he has not one iota of data to support that the engine was running at any other temperature but his post is written as though that previous hot running temperature was a fact.

What a load of crap. I appreciate the information being posted here for the purpose of illustrating how much BS there is floating around the internet under the guise of "experts" who use an eloquent writing style and a few big words.

DougM
 
From my days back at Fel-Pro..... The varying size holes in the gasket for the cooling system between the head and block are to direct flow so that the WHOLE head gets reasonably good flow. Drill some of the little holes and you will get more flow and likely better cooling near the drilled out hole but you have also reduced flow somewhere else, maybe somewhare that is running pretty hot.

As for the running cooler with a tstat vs without.... I could see the back pressure from the tstat slightly reducing cavitation at the pump
 
Back
Top Bottom