Given the debrief on 2M used at CM2007 I'm not convinced they are "better" in every instance.
Since I wrote the majority of that thread, I am curious as to why you jump to that conclusion?
The only issues were that RS didn't have anyone to man the 2M base station. I believe there was an illness or something like that. This was not a big deal since there wasn't any defined role for the base station anyway. I believe in future years they will have this worked out. In fact, I gave a good example of how they
could have used a HAM base station to coordinate the canceled trails on the last day. CB will NEVER work as a base station due to the extremely limited distance.
The other issue is that we didn't have the correct information on how to use the local repeaters. I believe Ali has this worked out now and he spent some time talking with the repeater owner on his last trip to Moab. Basically, we were using "published" information (something we found on a web site) that was out of date. Use of the repeaters would further extend the communication to ~100mi radius of Moab.
Even without using the repeater we were clearly picking up guys that were WAY out in the boonies. Every trail that I was on had at least 2 with HAM radios. One guy on E-Hill only had a HAM. I have not seen the final stats, but I know that RS was trying to keep track of those with HAM radios. Unfortunately, they did not ask everyone at the Tech Inspection even though it was on their inspection sheet so the totals at CM07 will be less than actuals.
My ability to reach out a long distance was very helpful on the caravan up to Moab. I was talking with Steve on the 2M and told him to head out since I was running late to the North Portal. I didn't catch up to the group until well North of Cuba but they maintained their speed, met up with the Espa guys, and kept rolling. There was no "where is Mike?" concern because I could talk 25+ miles, car-to-car, and let them know exactly where I was.
In summary, at CM07, those (albeit few) of us with 2m had significantly better communications than those with only a CB.
-Mike-