dog-bite -- more lawyers --

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 28, 2003
Threads
220
Messages
2,028
-- THAT'S what we need --

-- these trips used to be fun -- one bad apple spoiling the bunch -- :(

e


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dog mauls girl's face
5-year-old has surgery to restore part of her lip after PETCO customer's rottweiler attacked her in store





BY ANN GIVENS
STAFF WRITER

January 27, 2006


Diane Christian knows how her daughter loves dogs. So when she saw little Danielle patting a friendly looking rottweiler in PETCO Monday afternoon, she thought nothing of it.

Then she heard a horrible sound - a growl and the snapping of teeth - and looked down to see 5-year-old Danielle's face covered in blood.

"It was very traumatic," said Christian, 41, of Bay Shore. "I picked her up and started running around, looking for someone to help. There was a lot of blood."

After a four-hour surgery to reattach her upper lip, Danielle is still recovering at Southside Hospital in Bay Shore. And Christian said more surgeries lie ahead.

"My child will never look the same because of this," she said.

The rottweiler was not on sale at the Bay Shore PETCO; it belonged to a shopper. PETCO has a policy of inviting animals to shop with their owners, a company spokesman said.

But Christian said letting pets interact with customers invites trouble. She's retained a lawyer, Kenneth Mollins of Melville, and plans to take legal action against the dog's owner and/or PETCO, possibly as early as today.

"The store invites consumers in with pets; they encourage interaction. That's a prescription for problems," Mollins said, adding that the dog's caretaker should have known that it was dangerous. The man who took the rottweiler to PETCO was not its owner, Mollins said. The owner is Lori Koch, of Merrick, he said.

Koch could not be reached for comment yesterday, and Mollins said he hasn't been able to reach her since the incident.

Hempstead Town spokesman Mike Deery said the owner took the dog to the town's animal shelter after the incident, and asked that it be euthanized. Deery said the shelter plans to put the dog down within about a week, although there has been no court order mandating the dog be destroyed.

PETCO spokesman Don Cowan said the store allows pets to accompany their owners shopping because it's fun, and they haven't had enough serious incidents over the years to discourage that policy. He said he doesn't know the details of the Bay Shore incident, but PETCO has launched an investigation.

In general, however, he said PETCO expects pet owners to take responsibility for their pets. "It's up to the pet parents to decide whether their pet is docile enough to come into the store."

For Christian, what is especially sad is that her daughter, who loves animals and has a dog and three cats herself, suddenly is afraid of them. "She keeps saying, 'Mommy, he was so cute. Why did he bite at me?'" Christian said.
 
There are so many reasons these pet stores shouldn't allow people to take their dogs inside and this is right up there with disease transmission in unvaccinated puppies/younger dogs; such as parvo, distemper, corona, etc.

I am totally opposed to people taking any dog into a store such as petco or pet smart.

I don't care how friendly you dog is to you, you can never be sure what it might do to others if it is annoyed. Our Lab would take a bullet for any of my family, but I don't trust him around small children or even adults he doesn't know for even just a second.
 
Critter said:
There are so many reasons these pet stores shouldn't allow people to take their dogs inside and this is right up there with disease transmission in unvaccinated puppies/younger dogs; such as parvo, distemper, corona, etc.

I am totally opposed to people taking any dog into a store such as petco or pet smart.

I don't care how friendly you dog is to you, you can never be sure what it might do to others if it is annoyed. Our Lab would take a bullet for any of my family, but I don't trust him around small children or even adults he doesn't know for even just a second.

I agree - particularly in a strange (to the pet) environment. Awful sequence of events....
 
Not a good situation. Sounds like the child was slightly unsupervised and same with the dog.

I dont know about you guys, but when my child is meeting a dog she doesnt know, I am there with the child and the dog's owner to coach the introduction. Same thing if my dog is meeting a child or person for the first time. I am there over seeing the whole interaction so I can step in if I see the dog isnt comfortable.
 
"...friendly looking rottweiler..." ??? Um, no, I don't think so.

Don't ever let your kids pet animals you don't know.

Not petco's fault. The owner and the parent are the ones at fault.

flippin' lawyers.
 
I can't stand this, poor breeders, even worse owners are killing breeds that use to be trust worthy ( I am sure there are still a few good ones). I hear kids talk about how mean their dog is and how it will fight anything, great. Damn I'm tried of stupid people. Can we euthanize stupid people? MAybe we need a office of people control....oh yea we have that. Sorry really pissses me off to see animals suffer becuase of people ignorance, ego, etc. Rotties were a great breed.
 
i was walking into a PETCO with my wife and the APCA was there trying to get people to adopt dogs. Well, long story short, I got bit by a bull dog. I wasnt doing anything but walking in to buy food for my dog - it sucked and it hurt. I couldnt imagine getting mauled in the face.
 
I would not let strange kids pet my Rottweiller. Simple enough. He never bit one.
 
As a former rottie owner, I agree that they were not being supervised. My rottie was the best dog that anyone could ask for. However, anytime he was meeting someone new I was always right there, usually with one arm around him and one on his leash. It is unfortunate for the little girl that 2 adults negligence will leave her scarred for the rest of her life.
 
my last rottie was a total sweethart with strangers, the ups guy used to walk right into the backyard to leave packages...said he was more worried my buddies lab would bite him. does that mean that i;d let some little kid come meet her. no. (now the other two rotties i had, they were great when i was around, but i'm pretty sure they'd eat the ups man if he came in the backyard. but that was their job.)

and parents that let their kids go around unsupervised should be shot. i think those kid leashes are the best things in the world. my dog's trained to stay by me, but kids are way too curious to be trusted.
 
I think it's funny how everyone jumps eric over the p/b's but we can talk freely about rotties. I don't like pits. I have seen too many just snap and go after other dogs. I have had to pry too many other dogs out of their jaws. I was fortunate to have such a good rottie. I think a lot of it was enviroment. Until he was 6-7 months old some one was with him almost 24/7.
 
i have noticed that dogs are usually not comfortable around smaller children unless they are given a chance to get used to them. My min pin doesn't bite people but she has snapped at my very young cousin because the little girl kept getting in her face and carrying her akwardly.

My dad had to put down a german shepard that he had trained by a police dog trainer. The dog growled at a couple kids because there was about 10 kids cornering it and it felt threatened.

lunyou
 
stinkyfj60 said:
Not a good situation. Sounds like the child was slightly unsupervised and same with the dog.

I dont know about you guys, but when my child is meeting a dog she doesnt know, I am there with the child and the dog's owner to coach the introduction. Same thing if my dog is meeting a child or person for the first time. I am there over seeing the whole interaction so I can step in if I see the dog isnt comfortable.

Bingo.

Parent and pet "handler" (said it wasn't the owner) were both negligent. Of course, Petco encouraged that environment, and, sorry, they are also partially responsible if they did not adequately inform customers of the safety rules of their policy (proper signage, etc.). Encouraging the interaction of strangers and other people's pets requires caution.

A few minutes of the parent's time and cooperation by the handler could have prevent this.
 
I've said it before, and I will keep on saying it. When are people going to realize that pit bulls and rotts are not worth the risk?

Eric, you bring up lawyers in your post. Should the little girl and her family just live with it?
 
CSA said:
I've said it before, and I will keep on saying it. When are people going to realize that pit bulls and rotts are not worth the risk?

Eric, you bring up lawyers in your post. Should the little girl and her family just live with it?

Um, how is it petco's fault? (according to the article the lawyer is planning on suing them)

I would say most of the fault lies with the parent. Who lets a 5 year old unsupervised in a store - much less a store with unfamiliar animals with sharp, pointy teeth?

She can sue herself.

The other owner may have liability, but come on, time to take some responsibility for your own (in)action.


5 years old
unsupervised

makes no difference where it is or who else is around.

that is negligent of the parent. period.

Unfortunately in the environment we have now the lawyers have trained us to accept their view that the ones with the deepest pockets have liability for everyone else's actions. We are continuing our spiral towards a spineless society. Do we really need to have our gubment, supermarkets, etc responsible for our own actions?

If a guy attacked me in a supermarket and punched me, I would not sue the supermarket. It is not their responsibility to provide bodyguards to all the customers.


EDIT

Missed a few points the first time reading it. The owner of the dog wasn't even involved. Yet this asshat lawyer is looking to sue the owner. Jackass. Just because the lawyer claims "they encourage interaction" does not mean that you suspend all rational thought and let your kid wander over to an unknown rottie and turn your back.

Parent should get smacked down. I feel bad for the kid, but as a parent in that situation, there is only one place to point the blame. Yourself.
 
Last edited:
being America we'll all prolly get sued for discussing it. If I had to guess I'd say the dog's owner will bear the brunt of the liability.
 
the parent was negligent, in my eyes, in not acting like any other reasonable adult in watching her kid in the store --

-- and the pet owner was negligent for bringing the dog to the store, if the owner knew of the dog's propensity to bite --

-- but how is petco negligent??
 
i just hate PI attorneys with a passion and think they darken our society and our country --

-- i am much for carl llewellyn and his idead of TORT REFORM -- !!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom