Yeah, when I re-read that post it made me think I was looking at the old model and that the new ones might be different. Even so, I don't k ow how you get enough water on the mat to even matter, unless you're in and out a lot in snow. As for dirt, it would be the same. If you let dirt build up enough that it overflows any of the mats we are discussing, then the mat is not the problem! I like the look of the OEM, but looks like there is no protection at the pedals, and potentially some exposed carpet at 2nd row sides. Really a hard decision for me, even though it may seem trivial to some. Having the same issue with picking an iphone13 car charger to mount to a pro clip.