Tire fitment vs travel

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

1. Reguardless of what spring you use, J's, Slee, Skyjacker, OME comps, or air bags - The upward travel of the axle is going to be stopped by the bumpstops, or the shocks, or hitting the body, or in a really bad case, by fully compressing the springs till the coils hit each other.

Heath, yes it does not matter what spring you use to achieve lift, but you never answered my question as to how much lift you have with J's on a unloaded truck.

2. 2" bumpstops will stop the axle travel before you bottom out L shocks, reguardless of 2", 3", 4", 5" or 6" of lift.

3. Assuming we're not in some really odd spring situation where the coils can't compress anymore, and we've bumpstoped 2" to keep the shocks from bottoming out. The upward travel is going to be limited by said bumpstop.

4. Given 1, 2, and 3, since the axle stops in the same place for 2-6" (assuming no change in arms or drop brackets, since neither was available when you wrote what I quoted) how big a tire you can fit is going to be the same for 2-6" of lift.

So based on your point 4, I can fit a 37" tire with 2" of lift as well as I can fit it with 6" of lift? Also, technically the axle does not stop in the same place for a 2" lift or a 6" lift since the otherside of the axle is typically further down due to the larger lift, so the angle of the axle to the body is different. However there are so many variables involved with that, that it does not help to debate that. One example is you will run into the frame with larger tires instead of the inside wheelwell. On the Shortbus, where the wheel openings are not an issue, I had to run 1.5" wheel spacers and 3" offset wheels to keep the tire from hitting the frame when fully compressed. I also run 4" bumpstops and that is with 6" of lift.



Originally Posted by sleeoffroad View Post
Re: 4. It is not. You move the plane on which the axle moves away from the body (so yes you change up and down travel). Also, 35's will rub the body way before the 2" bumpstop is reached. So the tire size you can fit for a 2" and 6" lift is not the same. .

Originally Posted by Walking Eagle View Post
Even if you're not using L's, and using 2" bumpstops, and not bottoming out the shocks, the tire clearance is EXACTLY the same.

Originally Posted by sleeoffroad View Post
Yes, when compressed, but that is only 1/2 the picture. .
ok.

Originally Posted by Walking Eagle
So first you say the tire size you can fit isn't the same, then you agree it is.

I agree the wheel well is the same size, I do not agree the clearance is the same irrespective of tire size. If you look at the original statement that you quoted off the website you will see that it says

to RUN 35's. It is one thing to stuff a tire into a wheel well and say it fts. It is another to run it and be able to go through all suspension motions and all conditions and have a well rounded setup.

Based on your statements, it doesn't matter what tire size you run, they all fit the same in the wheel openings. That is simply not true.

2" of lift with 31's - Don't have to bumpstop at all
2" of lift with 33's - Same thing
2" of lift with 35's - you have to bumpstop to prevent rubbing
2" of lift with 27's - probably can't drive it on the street at all.

So why does that happen. Because the plane of articulation is moved away from the body and frame. What we are saying is that with 5" of lift, the plane is moved away far enough so that the suspension can cycle through most of it range without having to be limited for 35's.

I know this is nitpicking, but you are doing the same to our statements.

Please note that I have never brought shocks into this. I am talking about lift. Are there better shock options out there if you want to go custom yes, can you fine tune a suspension for a specific application like Nay did with FOR, yes. Would longer shocks be nice to run with the 6" springs, yes. But that is not what we are discussing now.

We simply state that 3" of lift (and you do not have 3" of lift with J's and no load, unless your springs have collapsed) is not enough to run 315's comfortably without repeatedly hitting the rear bump stops.
 
Last edited:
Define no uptravel.

Anything in the 3" range.


Obviously the strict definition of no uptravel would be the axle sitting on the bumpstops at ride height, and I'm guessing that's not what you mean.

I mean limited.

J's and L's are ment to work together, no?

No, it was never designed as such by OME, If you read that whole article you would know where it came from. L's was a direct response to Slee Off-Road asking OME to make us the longest shock that they could technically do with a direct bolt on mounting.

J's existed way before that for a different market.

OME seems to think there is enough up travel in that combination.

OME does not sell that as a kit. Actually if you look at OME documentation they do not have lift KITS. The only part number they have for a KIT is for Jeeps.

Bumpstoping to protect the L's, gives you the same tire clearance reguardless of spring height.

Not technically true as explained elsewhere.


I'd agree with a statement like this:

"4. Joe Blow says I can run 315's (or 35's) with just the J springs. Is that true?

As mentioned earlier, there are many variables, and for some the answer to this might be yes. However, Slee feels that the only way to clear 35" tires and allow adequate up travel is about a 5" lift. Anything less we consider an unacceptable compromise."

That is probably stated better. One thing to remember is that we do not sell on-line. Every customer that buys from us talks to us and from those discussions we determine what is the best option for the customer. However it is not just up travel why we feel that it is better to have more lift.

Course, that then begs the question as to if you feel there is adequate up travel with your 4" lift (or anyone else’s).

It depends on the conditions the truck is used in. Rock crawling vs expedition wheeling. We have these discussions with customers and advise them accordingly. 4" for rock crawling is not enough according to us. Not only due to the tire clearance but also total ground clearance and all the other aspects in rock crawling that comes into play.

For expedition travel it is, our spring rate is stiffer than OME so we control the truck better on hi-speed travel for heavily loaded trucks. So the chances of bottoming out the truck is less. Also, distances traveled are normally greater and it is a simple fact that a 4" truck is easier to drive than a 6" truck.
 
I'm running 35's with 2.5 inches of lift. I did nothing to the bumpstops and still have my flares all on. They fit no problem. I have ramped it before. I think the five inches of lift thing was just a marketing gimmick to sell more parts. I mean 35's will fit with stock suspension.
DSCF0455.JPG
 
I'm running 35's with 2.5 inches of lift. I did nothing to the bumpstops and still have my flares all on. They fit no problem. I have ramped it before.

No rubbing, did not rip the mudflaps off?


I think the five inches of lift thing was just a marketing gimmick to sell more parts. I mean 35's will fit with stock suspension.

Sure, that is how we sell parts :D
 
Running 35's is something I've been contemplating recently, and I read all related threads.

Christo, I follow your statement about the plane of articulation being moved down with increased lifts. That makes sense. The tire will be stuffed into the wheel well at a different angle depending on how far away the axle is to begin with.

I'm not sure if I understand the part about low lifts being on the bumpstops more.
Please correct me where I'm wrong.
For example:

I'm running 850's and 863's on a heavily loaded rig.
I just put 15mm worth of spacers on my front end yesterday.

I measured my shock down-travel before putting the spacers on and got 3.75 inches. From the 10" of total travel that leaves 6.25" up travel (assuming I can use most of that before hitting the bumpstops).
After adding the spacers, I now have only 3" of shock down-travel and 7" up.
That is very biased to up-travel.
If I switched to L-shocks and added 2" bumpstops, I would still have 6" up and 5" down, right? 6" up is pretty much what I have sitting on the 850's with factory bump stops.

Hayes
 
Doesn't look like he's running mudflaps in the picture.

There is of course, the question of slight variations in "35 inch tires."

Sure, a big fat 315 Toyo MT might rub, but what about a 315 ProComp XMT with narrower tread width?



No rubbing, did not rip the mudflaps off?
 
No rubbing, did not rip the mudflaps off?
Yeah I understand what you are saying. I took the mudflaps off. Because rock crawling and mudflaps don't mix very well.
 
I'm not sure if I understand the part about low lifts being on the bumpstops more.

For example, when we measured Romers truck and he had 863's at the time, I believe we needed 4" of bumpstop extension to stop the tire before it made contact with the flare and mudflap.

If you now install that bumpstop, and you articulate or do higher speed dirtroads you will hit the bumpstops. The only way to get away from that situations is more lit.


Please correct me where I'm wrong.
For example:

I'm running 850's and 863's on a heavily loaded rig.
I just put 15mm worth of spacers on my front end yesterday.

I measured my shock down-travel before putting the spacers on and got 3.75 inches. From the 10" of total travel that leaves 6.25" up travel (assuming I can use most of that before hitting the bumpstops).
After adding the spacers, I now have only 3" of shock down-travel and 7" up.
That is very biased to up-travel.
If I switched to L-shocks and added 2" bumpstops, I would still have 6" up and 5" down, right? 6" up is pretty much what I have sitting on the 850's with factory bump stops.
Hayes

We are talking about adding bumpstops for tire clearance, not to protect shocks, which normally ends up being more than 2", so that is where you loose the uptravel.
 
Yeah I understand what you are saying. I took the mudflaps off. Because rock crawling and mudflaps don't mix very well.

I do agree with that, but I have also posted before that we can not state there is no rubbing when there is actually some. Yes, we are ultra conservative but you have to remember that mud is only a small portion of the people out there buying stuff.
 
I mean 35's will fit with stock suspension.


I did that for a couple of weeks between when I got my new tires and got my lift installed. Played around the afternoon I put the tires on, and about ripped the mudflaps off cause I hadn't done anything with the bumpstops. Then I dropped the bumpstops, and ran it. Rode like crap on rough roads cause it kept pounding the bumpstops, but what do you expect with 170,000 miles on the springs, and worn out shocks.

Here's a couple of pictures from a couple weeks ago. You can see that the drivers side is completely stuffed. The passenger side is completely extended. Any more extended and it'd be in the air.

This is with J's. Had I 6" springs, what would be different? What would be different is it would have taken more force to compress the drivers side. Even if the spring rates were the same - more inches of compression, x pounds per inch = more force to compress. Since it would have taken more force before the spring was completely compressed, it would be pushing the body to the passenger side more. The body wouldn't be as level as it is. The front is already maxed out - though not to the bump stops - the drivers side front is in the air - there is no more articulation to be had up front. Now, you could say that the front would have started up higher, and then been able to compress further, but since it's not hit the bumpstops, the force supplied by the spring at that amount of compression is enough to create enough force to support the whole front (one wheel in air). So I doubt I would have actually gained much more compression. I don't say any more, cause some of the extra force from 6" springs in the back, would likely compress it a bit more, but with the limited articulation in the front, I'd still be lifting a front tire, and I'd still be pushing the body over more.

The passenger's side rear would be in the same position it is in the photos if the same L shocks are used, cuase it can't extend any more than the shock will allow.
Extreme Extension.webp
EXTREME STUFFAGE.webp
 
For example, when we measured Romers truck and he had 863's at the time, I believe we needed 4" of bumpstop extension to stop the tire before it made contact with the flare and mudflap.

If you now install that bumpstop, and you articulate or do higher speed dirtroads you will hit the bumpstops. The only way to get away from that situations is more lift.

On the high speed dirt roads, you can also add stiffer shocks, that will keep you from bouncing off the bumpstops. So that's not the only way.


We are talking about adding bumpstops for tire clearance, not to protect shocks, which normally ends up being more than 2", so that is where you loose the uptravel.


Who is talking about this? I'm talking pretty much exclusively about 2" bumpstop extensions. That's the only thing that makes the comparison of tire fitment on 3, 4, 5 or 6" lift valid.
 
On the high speed dirt roads, you can also add stiffer shocks, that will keep you from bouncing off the bumpstops. So that's not the only way.

But not in rock crawling,


[Hayes]
Who is talking about this? I'm talking pretty much exclusively about 2" bumpstop extensions. That's the only thing that makes the comparison of tire fitment on 3, 4, 5 or 6" lift valid.[/QUOTE]

I was answering the question from Hayes.
 
I don't think Slee is saying what you seem to be saying.....i.e. "You need 5" lift to run 35's". He knows that's not true. He's pointing out that unless you built the 80 in a certain way....limitations and compromises will occur which effect:

*Ride quality
*Rubbing
*Possible damage to vehicle parts
*ETC.

I've had 80's at:

2.5"
3"
3.5"
4.5"
5"
5.5"
6"

Believe it. Between my '93 and espeically the LX450, I've had all scenarios on and driven/tested.

To side with you: ALL scenarios had 35's on the truck. So, you can "run 35's".
To side with Slee: My best driving/wheeling experience was with the 5, 5.5 and 6" heights. Especially the 6" with stiffer springs, new front arms with corrected caster and proper wheel placement. So, to me...(and Slee?)...the best way to "run 35's" is with the proper gear.

I can tell you that the J-spring sway sucked. I far prefer my new setup despiteit costing a fortune. I tried to go cheap....but ended up wasting time and spending even more than I had too. My goal however was a perfect riding truck so I'd leave my 100 at home more often.
 
So based on your point 4, I can fit a 37" tire with 2" of lift as well as I can fit it with 6" of lift?

No. You've missed the point completely. If L shocks are run. And 2" bumpstops are in place to protect said L shocks. Then you can fit as big a tire with 3" lift as you can with 6" lift. The only question is if you feel that there is enough up travel with each configuraion. That's a matter of differing opinions, not so much a matter of fact.



2" of lift with 31's - Don't have to bumpstop at all
2" of lift with 33's - Same thing
2" of lift with 35's - you have to bumpstop to prevent rubbing
2" of lift with 27's - probably can't drive it on the street at all.

Again, this isn't what I was talking about. More along the lines of

2" of lift with 2" bumpstops fit 35's and give the same uptravel as stock
4" of lift with 2" bumpstops fit 35's and gives 2" more uptravel than stock
6" of lift with 2" bumpstops fit 35's and gives 4" more uptravel than stock
 
I did that for a couple of weeks between when I got my new tires and got my lift installed. Played around the afternoon I put the tires on, and about ripped the mudflaps off cause I hadn't done anything with the bumpstops. Then I dropped the bumpstops, and ran it. Rode like crap on rough roads cause it kept pounding the bumpstops, but what do you expect with 170,000 miles on the springs, and worn out shocks.

So here you are illustrating my exact point. It wasn't the fact that your spring were old and worn out, it was because your frame was to close to the body. Why did the situation improve when you lifted the truck?


Here's a couple of pictures from a couple weeks ago. You can see that the drivers side is completely stuffed. The passenger side is completely extended. Any more extended and it'd be in the air.

This is with J's. Had I 6" springs, what would be different?

How much lift do you have? Our experience is with J's on a unloaded truck is about 4-5".

What would be different is it would have taken more force to compress the drivers side. Even if the spring rates were the same - more inches of compression, x pounds per inch = more force to compress. Since it would have taken more force before the spring was completely compressed, it would be pushing the body to the passenger side more. The body wouldn't be as level as it is. The front is already maxed out - though not to the bump stops - the drivers side front is in the air - there is no more articulation to be had up front. Now, you could say that the front would have started up higher, and then been able to compress further, but since it's not hit the bumpstops, the force supplied by the spring at that amount of compression is enough to create enough force to support the whole front (one wheel in air). So I doubt I would have actually gained much more compression. I don't say any more, cause some of the extra force from 6" springs in the back, would likely compress it a bit more, but with the limited articulation in the front, I'd still be lifting a front tire, and I'd still be pushing the body over more.

The passenger's side rear would be in the same position it is in the photos if the same L shocks are used, cuase it can't extend any more than the shock will allow.

This is web wheeling at its best. Also pure speculation unless you put a truck in there with 6" of lift (using springs correctly for loaded weight of the truck) you can no state anything re: body more pushed over or not.

Also, please leave shocks out of this discussion.
 
Back
Top Bottom