That is a tough decision, I like ARB bumpers, but I also like Slee's "shortbus" front bumper. Slee's is tougher not doubt. I debated the same thing. I went with the ARB because I have had one before on my 4runner and I liked the protection it provided to the headlights when traveling through the brush in the middle of Nevada. It also saved me a couple of times while rockcrawling.
After all of that rambling, I guess I am saying...good luck with the decision.
Jack
P.S. The

took care of my stock bumper on a Deer Valley trail run

so I can't help you on a front bumper.